Home / National News / George Zimmerman Witness Can't Say Who Threw First Punch


(SANFORD, Fla.) — A woman who was talking on the phone to Trayvon Martin moments before he was shot and killed by George Zimmerman acknowledged on the stand Thursday that she does not know whether Zimmerman or Martin started the fatal fight.

The testimony of Rachel Jeantel, 19, was dissected over two days of often-testy cross-examination by Zimmerman’s lawyers, in which she was challenged on her assertion that she heard Martin say “get off” just before he was shot.

Zimmerman, 29, is on trial for second-degree murder in Martin’s death on Feb. 26, 2012. Martin, 17, was unarmed, but Zimmerman maintains he shot the teenager in self-defense.

Jeantel, a key prosecution witness in the racially charged trial, testified that she was talking on the phone with Martin when he told her a “creepy ass cracker” was following him. She told defense lawyer Don West that “cracker” is how she referred to white people in her community.

She had testified that she “could hear” Martin say “get off” to Zimmerman, although West said that during a taped interview with the prosecutor before the trial she had said that she “couldn’t hear.” West suggested that prosecutor Bernie de la Rionda coached her to say she could hear Martin.

Jeantel, 19, put her hands on her head as she listened in court Thursday to the audio of her interview with de la Rionda, but what she said on the tape was not 100-percent clear. After the tape played Jeantel insisted that she said she could hear Martin, but that prosecutor de la Rionda did not understand her.

However, West got Jeantel to acknowledge under oath that she didn’t know if Zimmerman or Martin started the fight the night the teen died.

Unfortunately your browser does not support IFrames.

“The last thing you heard was something hitting somebody?” West asked her.

“Trayvon got hit,” Jeantel said.

“You don’t know that, do you?” the defense lawyer said.

“No sir,” she said.

“You don’t know that he didn’t take his fist and drive it into Zimmerman’s face, do you?” the lawyer pressed.

“No sir,” Jeantel replied.

The combative exchange was part of her nearly seven hours of testimony over two days. She started the day appearing subdued. Her demeanor was so different from the hostile tone she had toward Zimmerman’s lawyer on Wednesday that West asked Jeantel, “You seem so different from yesterday. I’m just checking, did someone talk to you last night about your demeanor in court?”

Jeantel was forced to admit that she did not write a letter that was sent to Martin’s mother describing what she allegedly heard on a phone call with Martin moments before he was shot. It came when West asked her to read the letter aloud in court.

“Are you able to read that at all?” West asked.

Jeantel, head bowed, eyes averted, whispered into the court microphone, “Some but not all. I don’t read cursive.”

It sent a hush through the packed courtroom. She was unable to read any of the letter save for her name, date and the words “thank you.”

Jeantel said that she dictated the letter to someone who wrote it for her. West then proceeded to grill Jeantel over why she wasn’t specific with Martin’s mother about some of the things she heard over the phone, suggesting that her version of what she heard on the phone that night was not complete.

The testimony was an attempt to raise questions about the veracity of Jeantel’s testimony.

Rachel Jeantel was the last person to speak on the phone with Martin moments before he was shot to death by Zimmerman.

During cross-examination Thursday, Jeantel also testified that when she was interviewed under oath on April 2 by prosecutor Bernie de la Rionda she was sitting next to Trayvon Martin’s mother and that influenced what she told the prosecutor.

During nearly two hours of cross-examination Wednesday, West tried to raise questions about her version of events and accused her of telling several lies under oath, including about her whereabouts during Martin’s wake.

“Under oath, you created a lie and said you went to the hospital?” asked West.

“Yes,” responded Jeantel.  She said she lied because she didn’t want to see the body.

Jeantel became increasingly agitated and scoffed when West told her that she would have to continue testifying.

Tracey Martin eventually reached out to Jeantel after looking at his son’s phone log, Jeantel said. She added that she expected law enforcement to reach out to her, but none did, apparently, until the Florida Department of Law Enforcement contacted her much later.

Zimmerman said he was defending himself from Martin after the unarmed teenager allegedly confronted him, knocked him down and banged his head on the sidewalk. Prosecutors allege that the former neighborhood watch captain profiled and followed the teenager before killing him.

Copyright 2013 ABC News Radio


Recent posts in National News