(CINCINNATI) — The videotaped testimony of a paralyzed man, whose communication through only eye blinks to police was used to identify his alleged killer, is allowed to be shown in court, an Ohio judge ruled on Tuesday.
Hamilton County Court Judge Beth Myers denied the motion by defense attorneys to ban the blinking testimony of 35-year-old David Chandler to be shown to jurors in the trial against his alleged shooter, Ricardo Woods.
Woods, 34, is accused of fatally shooting Chandler in the head and neck on Oct. 28, 2010. When police interviewed Chandler in the hospital on Nov. 2, he was paralyzed and using a ventilator to breathe, authorities said.
Based on a communication system set up by his family, Chandler was instructed by authorities to blink three times to indicate a “yes” and two times to indicate a “no” when asked to identify the person who shot him.
During the interview, when Chandler was shown a photograph of Woods, he reportedly blinked three times.
On Nov. 12, Chandler died of complications of his paralysis and gunshot wounds.
Woods was charged with murder, felonious assault and weapons counts. If convicted, he could face life in prison.
Woods’s attorney, Kory Jackson, told ABC News he wanted the video excluded from the trial because it was unreliable.
“Police set up these rules, and they asked him a series of questions,” he said of the videotape of Chandler’s testimony. “There are times he doesn’t blink at all in response to questions, there are times he blinks more than three times. So it is often unclear what exactly he is trying to communicate.”
Jackson said Chandler’s eye-blinking testimony was also problematic because authorities only showed him one photo and reportedly suggested to him that Woods was the person they believed was the suspect.
“They planted the idea in his mind, and then asked him to respond,” Jackson said.
Jackson said the two individuals who were in the car with Chandler when he was shot were both shown a line-up, and neither of them identified Woods as the shooter.
A spokesman for the Hamilton County prosecutor’s office declined to comment on the judge’s ruling because the case was still pending.
Woods is currently in custody at Hamilton County Jail.
The trial is scheduled to begin on April 29.
Copyright 2013 ABC News Radio
Recent posts in National News